7 Vegan Desserts to Make With Leftover Halloween Candy

Leftover Halloween candy is best treated as a baking ingredient. A handful can add texture to brownies or cupcakes; a larger stash can become bark, pudding, or a showpiece shake. These seven ideas make it easier to use the candy while it’s still around—and to share the results before the holiday baking season takes over.

Jump to the recipes

Before mixing anything into batter, sort the haul. Gelatin, eggs, carmine, honey, dairy ingredients such as milk, milkfat, butterfat, or whey, and confectioner’s glaze (shellac) are signs a candy isn’t vegan. Set those aside so they don’t end up in the finished treats.

Seven ways to bake with vegan Halloween candy

Some of these ideas call for a specific recipe; others are flexible enough to take whatever candy is left in the cupboard. Check the ingredients on each treat before using it.

Black Tap Tavern

1 Vegan Crazy Shake

A loaded shake turns leftover candy into a dessert with real visual impact. Start with New Leaf’s Choc’ Rockin’ Vegan Freakshake: a thick chocolate shake topped with a store-bought vegan brownie, chocolate sandwich cookies, chocolate chips, whipped cream, and nut butter cups.

Use the toppings you have. Vegan gummy worms can bring a fruity note to the chocolate, while extra cookies or candy can make the shake even more extravagant. It’s a generous portion, so plan to share—and bring a couple of extra-large straws.

Get the recipe

Namely Marly

2 Vegan M&M Cookies

Chocolate gems can take the place of chocolate chips in a cookie dough, giving coated candies a second life. You can bake the dough right away or freeze it for later. Chopped nut butter cups and coconut bars also fit well in the buttery mixture.

Standard M&Ms aren’t vegan. Look instead for options such as YumEarth’s Choco Yums, UNREAL’s Dark Chocolate Gems, or No Whey!’s Chocolate No No’s, and check the package ingredients.

Get the recipe

Beaming Baker

3 Peanut butter cup brownies

Brownies give nut butter cups a rich, chewy base. Fold pieces into the batter, then scatter more across the top. As they bake, the topping softens into pockets of chocolate and nut butter.

It’s a natural choice for a bake sale or a batch to bring to friends. Vegan nut butter cups work especially well here.

Get the recipe

The Conscious Plant Kitchen

4 Candy bar-stuffed cupcakes

A hidden candy center gives a familiar cupcake a more interesting bite. Make your preferred vanilla or chocolate batter and fill the liners as usual. Before baking, set a half-inch piece of caramel or chocolate candy on top of each portion; the rising batter should cover it.

Let the cupcakes cool fully before frosting with vegan buttercream or dipping them in vegan ganache. Finish with finely chopped candy for extra crunch.

Get the recipe

Chelsea Peachtree

5 Candy bark

Bark is the easiest option when the leftover mix is a little of everything. Melt plain or salted chocolate, spread it over parchment, and add whatever suits it: pretzels, popcorn, gummies, marshmallows, dried fruit, or chopped candy bars.

Refrigerate the slab for 30 minutes, then break it into pieces. The result is easy to portion and share.

Get the recipe

Minimalist Baker

6 Vegan Dirt Cake

Crushed cookies and creamy pudding make a simple base for gummy candy. The featured recipe uses homemade vanilla pudding, though a boxed vanilla or chocolate instant mix can simplify the process; Simply Delish is one option.

Gummy worms are the classic finish, but any vegan gummy candy can top the dessert. Simply Delish is linked as an instant pudding option.

Get the recipe

Cocomels

7 Caramel apples

For a batch of caramel apples, melt Cocomels caramels with a splash of coconut milk and coat the apples. Leave them plain or use the sticky surface to hold other toppings: chocolate drops, crushed nut butter cups, mini marshmallows, or cookie pieces.

This approach turns a small pile of assorted candy into a set of desserts with different finishes. Check that each topping is vegan before adding it.

Get the recipe

Pick a recipe based on what’s left: bark handles the mixed odds and ends, while brownies and cookies put chocolate candies to work. A little sorting first makes the leftovers easier to bake with—and the finished treats easier to share.